New Construction vs. Historic Homes in Fort Lauderdale – Which is Right for You?

Fort Lauderdale, with its sun-drenched coastlines, iconic waterways, and vibrant neighborhoods, continues to attract homebuyers from across the country. Whether you’re relocating to South Florida or investing in property, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is choosing between a new construction home and a historic property. Both options offer distinct advantages—and knowing which is right for you often comes down to your lifestyle, budget, and long-term goals.

As a trusted realty companies in Fort Lauderdale, FL, Star Bay Realty has helped hundreds of buyers navigate this choice. Let’s take a closer look at what each type of home offers, and how to decide which best suits your needs.

The Allure of New Construction Homes

Modern Amenities and Energy Efficiency

One of the biggest advantages of buying a newly built home is the access to modern amenities. From open floor plans and smart home technology to energy-efficient windows and appliances, new construction homes are designed with today’s lifestyles in mind. These homes often require little to no immediate upgrades, saving you both time and money.

Customizable Options

Buyers often get to choose their finishes, cabinetry, countertops, and even floor plans in new developments. This level of customization means you can design a space that truly reflects your taste and preferences.

Lower Maintenance Costs

Because everything in a new home is brand new—roofing, plumbing, electrical systems—you’re unlikely to face costly repairs for years. Many builders also offer warranties, providing peace of mind in case anything needs attention within the first few years.

Great for First-Time Homeowners or Busy Professionals

If you’re not interested in DIY renovations or maintaining older systems, new construction is often the smarter choice. Professionals, growing families, and retirees all appreciate the convenience and predictability new homes offer.

The Charm and Character of Historic Homes

Architectural Beauty and Timeless Design 

Historic homes in Fort Lauderdale boast architectural features that are difficult to replicate—think intricate crown molding, original hardwood floors, or hand-crafted staircases. These homes often tell a story, adding depth and character that newer constructions lack.

Established Neighborhoods and Mature Landscaping

Older homes are usually located in well-established communities close to downtown, the beach, or historic districts. These areas often offer mature trees, walkable streets, and a deep sense of community.

Investment Potential and Tax Incentives

In some cases, historic properties may qualify for preservation grants or tax credits for renovations. Additionally, these homes can appreciate significantly in value, especially if they’re well-maintained and located in a desirable part of Fort Lauderdale.

Perfect for Passionate Renovators and History Buffs

If you’re someone who values craftsmanship or enjoys bringing old beauty back to life, a historic home might be ideal. However, it’s crucial to budget for potential renovations and understand the local regulations regarding historical preservation.

Comparing Costs and Long-Term Value

Upfront Costs

New homes often come at a premium, especially if they’re located in newer developments or have been customized with luxury upgrades. However, they typically require less work post-purchase. 

Historic homes may have lower initial price tags (depending on condition), but they may also come with hidden costs—such as the need to update electrical systems, address structural issues, or meet current building codes.

Maintenance and Renovation

With new construction, maintenance is minimal in the first 5-10 years. In contrast, historic homes require more upkeep. However, many buyers see this as an investment in authenticity and long-term value.

Resale Value

Both types of homes can appreciate in value, but in different ways. New homes in rapidly developing areas may see value increase due to neighborhood growth, while historic homes can become more desirable as unique or rare properties in established districts.

Which is Right for You?

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your lifestyle: 

• Go with new construction if you want modern features, energy efficiency, low maintenance, and the ability to customize.

• Choose a historic home if you value character, unique design, and living in an established neighborhood—especially if you don’t mind putting in work over time.

Working with a knowledgeable real estate broker in Fort Lauderdale, FL is essential to make the best decision. A skilled broker can help you weigh the pros and cons based on your needs and guide you through either the new home buying process or the intricacies of purchasing and restoring a historic property.

How Star Bay Realty Can Help

At Star Bay Realty, we pride ourselves on supporting agents and clients alike with a flexible and rewarding business model. As an Orlando best real estate brokerage, we operate across Florida, including Fort Lauderdale, offering guidance in both new developments and historic neighborhoods.

We also operate as a 100 percent commission brokerage, which means our agents retain more of their hard-earned money—giving them more incentive to work tirelessly for their clients. Whether you're buying new construction, renovating a vintage gem, or investing in your next property, you’ll benefit from a team that’s committed, experienced, and empowered to deliver results.